A non issue with the Freedom Lift. Our swim ladder still works and there’s room to climb on but it’s a little tight between the dinghy and platform so you duck briefly before standing fully up. Wife is shorter and thinner. She doesn’t duck.
Think this concern is boat and mechanism specific. We load the dinghy with the engine on . The engine is on the opposite side (starboard) than the ladder (port). That gives you more room at the pointy end (bow).
On prior boats needed to take engine off as weight made it difficult to use davits. Definitely needed to take engine off for passage as it was unsafe. For passage would deflate dinghy and store on foredeck upside down. A dinghy even with the plug out will store a lot of water if pooped. Enough to distort how the boat floats and handles. See some folks put their fenders in their dinghy and do lashings above them to hold the fenders in. Never felt comfortable with that. Would be reluctant to have any dinghy on any device upright on a swim platform in serious weather. Even storing on the boat deck can cause troubles. Would leave plug out, fill with fenders and have a strong cover well attached to the deck not like the circumferential bungee cord I currently have. A filled dinghy will affect AVS and stability.
I think these are all good points. But as others have said, it depends a lot on your individual boat, how it handles certain conditions, how you operate it and what conditions you operate it in. Pretty much like everything else in boating, I guess.
Our setup, when I have it rigged for open water raises the top of the aft (stb) tube about 5' above the waterline. The dinghy does not shift at all in any direction. I've watched it closely while under way in many different conditions, including pretty substantial following seas and I've never seen a wave come anywhere close to pooping it. Not saying it is impossible, just that in about 1,000 hours underway it has not been an issue.
Also, because it sits on an angle toward the stern of the big boat with the top of the fwd (port) tube lower than the stb tube, a portion of the water that comes in would slosh out. It would hold some in the cockpit, but not filled to the gunnels on both sides.
Our old boat had stern davits, they raised the tender pretty high, but no matter how I lashed it down I couldn't stop the side to side swaying. It was annoying and hard on the tender. In big seas I worried about it more than I do our current setup.
Also, there are all different safety scenarios related to a tender. Yes, one of those is getting pooped and filling it with a few hundred gallons of water but so is launching from a high aft deck, getting it onto a foredeck, taking a heavy outboard (with a sharp prop) off and on, straining to pull an awkward tender into place....I could go on and on. You pick your poison.
Doug