I have been researching cruising for a few years, doing lots of reading and investigating. For the last 3 months I have been reading about trawlers.
The one thing I am taking away from this is boating has become a rich man's lifestyle. What's changed? It didn't used to be like that.
Hello Mick. I grew up on the water (born and raised aboard a 40'er) and you are correct: boating has changed. Folks (including ME!) expect the niceties.
For instance, we didn't have refrigeration until I was a teenager. Ditto television -- my dad didn't want one so that was that. Oil lanterns were the rule and power was not available. We didn't have a VHF radio until we were caught in a hurricane (weather changed) and so it goes.
Now I do have a refrigerator and a great deal of my thinking/planning concerns how to provide power so I can run it 24/7 even in the summertime. I think (hope) that with the addition of three more batteries I'll be able to swing it. However until the final bill is in on the new engine swap... no spending.
As Mother used to say:
The ideal boat sleeps two, feeds four and drinks six.
You can go as fancy as you like/can afford however I would encourage you to go small. Not as small as I have, but smaller is better in any number of ways.
For instance, when it comes time to wash the boat it takes me less than an hour and from stem to stern, she's scrubbed. Making the windows sparkle (which I really ought to do soon) is at most a 30 minute job.
You'll want to decide if you prefer a galley up or down. The top priorities need to be (in my opinion)
#1) Access to the engine. If you cannot reach the impeller easily, you won't change it. Ditto oil, etc. Maintenance delayed is co$tly. Very very $$$.
#2) No iron fuel tanks. That's an expensive fix when (not IF) they fail.
#3) Safety. Can you go forward in a blow to reset the anchor? (If you're a marina hopper that's not as critical.)
#4) Planning on anchoring a lot? Buy a too-big anchor, G4 chain and a windlass. You're not getting any younger and hauling in the chain/anchor sucks after the first time. Heck, during the first pull!
#5) A nice ride. She shouldn't roll your eyeballs out. You want to feel safe/secure aboard her, even if the seas kick up a bit.
#6) Of course the motor needs to be in good working condition, but you knew that.
#7) Don't ever buy any boat that needs extensive anything. You're not getting any younger. If you cannot take her away from the dock tomorrow, she's the wrong boat. And don't spend a dime on anything major until you've used her for at least six months (preferably a year)
Your wants and needs WILL CHANGE.
Okay, well, if that particular boat is The One, #7 can be tweaked. You can do whatever is minimal to make her yours/safe, etc. Every job has "While we're at it we really ought to do X, Y, and Z is a good idea too" along with unexpected problems. Escaping a boatyard is often far costlier than expected.
You can find a boat that meets your needs (and is close on the wants category) but it won't jump out in front of you. Be careful. Be smart. And realize unless the boat is a custom one-off, there is a sister ship out there.
As for doing it on $5k a month. In style you can -- fixed costs for life remain the same. (Insurance, taxes, maintenance be it a boat or a house)
What changes is the view. Mine's pretty decent. The view is the same, be it from a half-million dollar yacht or a 23' mini-trawler. The difference is the yacht probably has ice and lots of fresh, hot water. He's probably got some Porterhouse steaks in his freezer too.
I'll have to manage with freshly caught sheepshead. Yummy!
Goodness gracious, I sure did run on at the fingers...
Yes Mick. Boating has changed. It is still for plain folks. The Burl Ives of the world were something else. I suspect the generation they came from appreciated the anonymity that came with boating. We were "regular folks" and I've found boaters to be right nice -- those from all walks of life.
Boating unites and you will be able to spend what you have. It wouldn't be difficult to spend more, and I can guarantee it can be done for far less that your retirement income. With my budget, I don't eat out, seldom dock and keep expenses to a minimal. My "extravagance" is the internet -- $50 a month for five gigs.
That and engine swaps. My credit cards are not happy with me but I know by knuckling down I'll be back to debt free again. The burden of debt is not much fun so your plan to pay cash is just about perfect.
Good luck and I hope to see you along the waterways...