Bow thruster not producing much thrust

The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
HeadedToTexas said:
Took me a bit to come around to the current draw issue, but see that now. Vetus' page for this model includes an asterisk that notes "this model is design to be a compatible replacement for older Vetus BOW75 4.7kW units." Mine might draw more than 500 amps. No way that should be on 110 feet of 2/0 cable.
Click to expand...
4.7 KW (4,700 watts) ÷ 12 volts = 392 amps. From recollection, a DC motor running at below rated voltage shouldn't require more amps, it should slow down.

Even more keen to know how much of a voltage drop you're getting.

I would consider taking your start battery up the the bow thruster and wiring it with some 2' cables as an experiment. See if it gives you the push that you want and how much of a voltage drop. Then all you have to do is decide how many boat units you want to invest.

Ted
 
If you have space for new batteries forward it's not a particularly expensive proposition. A couple of small starting batteries, a small dc-dc charger and a few short cables are all that's required.

My boat was wired like the OP's when I got it. This was one of my first upgrades.
 
I burned my bow truster from a factory installed on ex. boat. bow truster to battery bank be 5-meter cable 90 mm2. voltage on truster on work 9-10V factory. for you install 1 starter battery 100-180Ah around 1000+ cca 1 meter from truster and see a huge difference.
 
O C Diver said:
4.7 KW (4,700 watts) ÷ 12 volts = 392 amps. From recollection, a DC motor running at below rated voltage shouldn't require more amps, it should slow down.

Even more keen to know how much of a voltage drop you're getting.

I would consider taking your start battery up the the bow thruster and wiring it with some 2' cables as an experiment. See if it gives you the push that you want and how much of a voltage drop. Then all you have to do is decide how many boat units you want to invest.

Ted
Click to expand...
I suggested doing a temporary start battery for a test in post #12, I guess that great minds think alike…
 
I will be doing the voltage testing this weekend, but I'm going to have to psych myself up to moving the main engine battery. That and eat some spinach. All in due time, of course.

In the meantime, the bottom diagram of these three is what I believe we are talking about. Both the thruster and windlass are currently powered from the house bank through the main busbar. The main engine and generator start batteries are only connected when the Auto Charging Relays meet their voltage requirements.
Escape thruster windlass rewire diagram.jpg

That bottom diagram shows the installation of new positive and negative busbars that connect the thruster and windlass to the main engine start battery. Both of those motors are behind switches and breakers or fuses, though my diagram only shows the switches. Is that an electrically sound and responsible way to accomplish the rewiring?
 
It looks ok to me, but I'm unclear where the alternator senses voltage to make sure both the house and start battery are full.

Ted
 
Important in this discussion is voltage drop at the wire to swaged terminal connection and from the terminal to motor post connection.
I wire brush to bright metal before crimping the exposed wire and the inside of the terminal the coat the wire with silicon dielectric grease before swaging. The grease provides a seal and provides a long term low resistant connect.
The connection at the motor post also needs similar treatment. That include the terminal surfaces, the post threads and the nut surfaces and threads. Again seal these with the dielectric grease.
Also the wire sizing and short runs are important.
My thruster is 24v with two group 31 agm batteries and about 6 ft total run with 2/0 cable works great.
The anchor winch is Lofrans 1500w 12 volt off the house bank. The alternator outputs over 100amps at 1100 rpm which makes a very noticable difference in winch operation versus battery only from a 1000amp hour bank.
Message keep all connection clean for best operation
 
My plan this weekend is to test volts and amps at the thruster when it is running. I will also inspect the connections as looking clean and tight is not the same as sound continuity.

Also on the list is to confirm how and where the alternator and starter tie into the main engine battery and house bank. I think I know, but you know how that goes. More as I know it. Thanks guys.
 
My bowthruster ran but was similarly anemic/ineffective in performance. A check of the Optima blue top(90AH)AGM start type battery OEM fitted right next to it showed it was cactus. Replaced with same( even used same securing set screws), improvement was spectacular. Advice is 2 batts are preferable but one seems fine and it`s how the boat was built. The battery gets charge via a connection to one of the dual purpose 8Ds that supply start and house.
As you don`t have a dedicated adjacent battery I think adding one will improve things a lot. But, if it`s how it was built, maybe it did work satisfactorily once, if so, discovering why it doesn`t now could be key.
 
I am running out of enthusiasm today and thinking has come easier than crawling around in the bilge. Here's a question for you guys with thruster batteries right next to your thrusters. Do you not have a disconnect switch somewhere readily accessible? Or is there a switch right there close for maintenance?

IMG_4477.jpeg


My boat has a thruster disconnect right by the wheel in the pilothouse. That means the 2/0 cables not only come from the house bank in the lazarette to the main bus, but then go up to that switch before reaching the motor control solenoids and lugs on the motor.

It also means that if I add a dedicated battery for the thruster, I would either have to abandon that switch or run the power to that switch and back. If the switch is important, then the main engine start battery is about as close to that switch as I can get with a battery.
 
O C Diver said:
...I'm unclear where the alternator senses voltage to make sure both the house and start battery are full.
Click to expand...
The main engine battery switch has two 4/0 cables. One connects to an auto charging relay then on to the main bus. The other connects to the main engine battery. The main engine starter connects to the other lug of that battery switch.

The main engine alternator connects to a 200 amp fuse before connecting to the main bus bar. The means the alternator only charges the main engine when the ACR senses the right voltage inputs. Alternator output is controlled by this Balmar regulator.

IMG_6318.jpeg
 
Comodave said:
I had a battery switch at the batteries. If you want to be able to turn it off at the helm put in remote controlled switch. I think Blue Seas make one.
Click to expand...
The only reason to disconnect the thruster from its power source is to work on the motor or its connections. That isn't going to happen without being up close and personal, so why not have the switch right there by the battery, yes?
 
That is what I have on our current boat as well as our last boat. The only reason to have a remote battery switch is if the contacts weld together and the thruster won’t shut off, then the remote would be nice.
 
HeadedToTexas said:
The main engine battery switch has two 4/0 cables. One connects to an auto charging relay then on to the main bus. The other connects to the main engine battery. The main engine starter connects to the other lug of that battery switch.

The main engine alternator connects to a 200 amp fuse before connecting to the main bus bar. The means the alternator only charges the main engine when the ACR senses the right voltage inputs. Alternator output is controlled by this Balmar regulator.

View attachment 159036
Click to expand...
You have to decide for yourself whether the house battery is getting charged completely. I've never liked 2 battery banks of possibly different chemistries and certainly of different sizes, with very different cable lengths being charged by one alternator. I assume this would only be a cruising problem as the house bank is charged by the inverter / battery charger from shore power.

Depending on how you change the power supply to the windlass and bow thruster, it might make more sense to charge the house bank with the engine alternator and charge the engine battery with a 12 VDC to 12 VDC charger off the house bank.

My personal preference was for 2 alternators, one for the house and one for the engine.

Ted
 
HeadedToTexas said:
I am running out of enthusiasm today and thinking has come easier than crawling around in the bilge. Here's a question for you guys with thruster batteries right next to your thrusters. Do you not have a disconnect switch somewhere readily accessible? Or is there a switch right there close for maintenance?

View attachment 159033

My boat has a thruster disconnect right by the wheel in the pilothouse. That means the 2/0 cables not only come from the house bank in the lazarette to the main bus, but then go up to that switch before reaching the motor control solenoids and lugs on the motor.

It also means that if I add a dedicated battery for the thruster, I would either have to abandon that switch or run the power to that switch and back. If the switch is important, then the main engine start battery is about as close to that switch as I can get with a battery.
Click to expand...
It's best practice to have switch near the battery. I never got around to installing one when everything got converted to 24 VDC. Instead, I had a fuse holder that I removed the fuse on.

The other option is a latching relay from Blue Seas. The relay I'm thinking of has 2 coils. Push a button to engage the relay. Push another to disengage. The coils don't remain energized.

Ted
 
HeadedToTexas said:
I am running out of enthusiasm today and thinking has come easier than crawling around in the bilge. Here's a question for you guys with thruster batteries right next to your thrusters. Do you not have a disconnect switch somewhere readily accessible? Or is there a switch right there close for maintenance?

View attachment 159033
Click to expand...
Just the switchboard breaker, though the thruster joystick has its own time limited "on" switch.
I have a disconnect switch at the helm for the windlass, as well as a switchboard breaker for it.
 
If it was me........ I would future proof it. By putting two 12v batteries in the bow using 4/0 wiring for now. When the time comes to replace the thruster. Install a 24v on and than move the jump wire to make 24v bank.
 
I don’t like running so much extra cable for high power devices like that. If you want to keep a helm disconnect, repurpose the switch to activate a remote solenoid/disconnect that enables the thruster.
 
Bmarler said:
I don’t like running so much extra cable for high power devices like that. If you want to keep a helm disconnect, repurpose the switch to activate a remote solenoid/disconnect that enables the thruster.
Click to expand...
Excellent idea! Thank you.
 
O C Diver said:
where the alternator senses voltage to make sure both the house and start battery are full.

Ted
Click to expand...
what voltage have with both the house and start battery are full..
alternator produces 14,2/14,5/15,5 depending alternator regulator ,current if need flow,if not need not flow.alternator must have stabil voltage by regulator factory settings. if current need flow ,alternator don't care is your battery empty,full and any other state
 
more said:
what voltage have with both the house and start battery are full..
alternator produces 14,2/14,5/15,5 depending alternator regulator ,current if need flow,if not need not flow.alternator must have stabil voltage by regulator factory settings. if current need flow ,alternator don't care is your battery empty,full and any other state
Click to expand...
Different battery chemistries have different bulk, absorption, and float voltages.

Further, batteries can have different amperage absorption rates. As an example, the OP could have a 200 amp alternator with an external regulator. In the bulk phase, the alternator may be putting out 200 amps. The chemistry of the house bank may easily be able to absorb 200 amps in the bulk phase. The issue becomes that the engine battery is near full (as it only starts the engine), but the house bank is down, and the external regulator is sensing a lower voltage. So when the external regulator puts the alternator in bulk (200 amp) phase, what limits the alternator from pushing a 100 amps or more into the start battery. If the start battery is open lead acid, it may take offense to 100 amps or more.

While it sounds logical to assume that amperage from the alternator goes to the lowest battery, you have to guarantee that it does, or bad things can happen.

Ted
 
All batteries are AGM. And while the alternator supplies current to the main busbar, the main engine and generator start batteries are behind Blue Sea automatic charging relays and are charged or isolated when the right conditions are met.
 
It took me a re-read to grasp that you were referring to a remote actuation of the main switch! Makes perfect sense. Thank you.
 
O C Diver said:
Different battery chemistries have different bulk, absorption, and float voltages.

Further, batteries can have different amperage absorption rates. As an example, the OP could have a 200 amp alternator with an external regulator. In the bulk phase, the alternator may be putting out 200 amps. The chemistry of the house bank may easily be able to absorb 200 amps in the bulk phase. The issue becomes that the engine battery is near full (as it only starts the engine), but the house bank is down, and the external regulator is sensing a lower voltage. So when the external regulator puts the alternator in bulk (200 amp) phase, what limits the alternator from pushing a 100 amps or more into the start battery. If the start battery is open lead acid, it may take offense to 100 amps or more.

While it sounds logical to assume that amperage from the alternator goes to the lowest battery, you have to guarantee that it does, or bad things can happen.

Ted
Click to expand...
Amps don’t get pushed, they get pulled. A battery will only accept as many amps *at a given voltage* as its chemistry and state of charge dictate. You don’t cook a battery by”pushing” too many amps through it. You cook it by supplying too high a voltage for too long, thus allowing it to pull more amps than its design (charge curve) intended.
 
NoRain said:
Amps don’t get pushed, they get pulled. A battery will only accept as many amps *at a given voltage* as its chemistry and state of charge dictate. You don’t cook a battery by”pushing” too many amps through it. You cook it by supplying too high a voltage for too long, thus allowing it to pull more amps than its design (charge curve) intended.
Click to expand...
It isn't more or less accurate to describe electrical current as being pulled or pushed.
Electrons in a conductor react to the difference in the fields they are exposed to.
You can demonstrate repulsion (being pushed) as easily as attraction (being pulled).
 
KnotYet: I respectfully 1) disagree with your first sentence; 2) agree with your second, but I think it’s not relevant to the discussion or point I was trying to make; and 3) I’d be interested in a specific example…using current flow as the motivator for the repulsion or attraction.

But my apologies, I really didn’t mean to get into a discussion about semantics, merely to correct the impression that you can somehow”push” current into batteries. In the example I was responding to: “So when the external regulator puts the alternator in bulk (200 amp) phase, what limits the alternator from pushing a 100 amps or more into the start battery. If the start battery is open lead acid, it may take offense to 100 amps or more. While it sounds logical to assume that amperage from the alternator goes to the lowest battery, you have to guarantee that it does, or bad things can happen.”, you cannot “push” current into a battery. If you have a charging source capable of supplying 200A, then that battery will only accept as much current as its chemistry permits - the internal resistance will limit the current flow into the battery. eg an FLA battery of 100AH capacity can accept only about 25-30 amps of current maximum. That is determined by several factors and can vary from manufacturer to manufacturer. But that is what will limit the alternator from “pushing a 100 amps or more into the start battery”. There are several reasons that bad things can happen, but the fact that the alternator is *capable* of supplying 200A is not one of them.
 
NoRain said:
KnotYet: I respectfully 1) disagree with your first sentence; 2) agree with your second, but I think it’s not relevant to the discussion or point I was trying to make; and 3) I’d be interested in a specific example…using current flow as the motivator for the repulsion or attraction.

But my apologies, I really didn’t mean to get into a discussion about semantics, merely to correct the impression that you can somehow”push” current into batteries. In the example I was responding to: “So when the external regulator puts the alternator in bulk (200 amp) phase, what limits the alternator from pushing a 100 amps or more into the start battery. If the start battery is open lead acid, it may take offense to 100 amps or more. While it sounds logical to assume that amperage from the alternator goes to the lowest battery, you have to guarantee that it does, or bad things can happen.”, you cannot “push” current into a battery. If you have a charging source capable of supplying 200A, then that battery will only accept as much current as its chemistry permits - the internal resistance will limit the current flow into the battery. eg an FLA battery of 100AH capacity can accept only about 25-30 amps of current maximum. That is determined by several factors and can vary from manufacturer to manufacturer. But that is what will limit the alternator from “pushing a 100 amps or more into the start battery”. There are several reasons that bad things can happen, but the fact that the alternator is *capable* of supplying 200A is not one of them.
Click to expand...
NoRain, I see where you are coming from. The excess current being 'pushed' into
your example battery is being converted into heat radiating from the battery in the
example, if not being converted into stored chemical energy. The current does go in, nonetheless. The determining factor is at what voltage the regulator cuts out.
 
Last edited:
Sorry to be contrary once again, but it does not go in….unless you raise the voltage to a point where it should not be — that’s one of the key factors in the “bad things happen” scenario I was referring to.

I guess the simplest example I could give is a battery at Float. Hook up a 200A charger and set the voltage to 13.4V and (assuming the start battery is full as in the example given) there will be no current flow. The battery is full and it cannot accept any more current at that voltage. If you ran the voltage up to 15V then there would be current flowing into the battery, and then the battery would start gassing, and that-there is bad things happening😜. Run it up to 16V and you’re into Equalization mode, which is a fancy term for controlled boiling. Actually intended for FLA batteries only although a couple manufacturers (eg LifeLine) employ it in a very limited and controlled way in their AGM line.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

D
Vetus bow thruster
2
Replies
30
Views
1K
Iggy
I
dhays
Time for new Thruster Bank I'm afraid 😟
Replies
26
Views
2K
Capt Ray
C
S
Replacement Vetus Bow and Stern Thruster Motors
Replies
13
Views
660
Jeff F
Jeff F
Waterford
Yacht Thruster failure
Replies
18
Views
544
BruceK
BruceK
dhays
Suggestions on DC2DC charger setup.
Replies
25
Views
2K
dhays
dhays

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom