I remember the discussion on the Vulcan and I purchased one for the Embark as a main and dropped the Bruce in the hatch for the backup.
Here is the pictures of what we have. While it sounds like some folks optimized the setup, I'm going with the setup as is. When we pull the anchor up we always are careful hauling up and setting the anchor in, regardless of the boat. I actually think it works well. Take a look and let me know why we need to do anything else. It fits snug and slightly compresses the rubber roller. I would assume if you hammered down you could have issues if the clutch wasn't adjusted right. Just don't have a rookie bring the anchor up and slam it. Anchored several times, no problem.
Its a nice snug fit. and releases easily. Tied a snubber to it to prevent any accidental release.
Should I be concerned? Comments?
Concerned? Don't think so.
This is why I have not ordered any parts to make changes to the setup. I want to see how things work first.
Way back when, I was sent pictures of a Vulcan on a H38. The bale bar had been removed. Pulled up tight, the top edge of the shank of the Vulcan was maybe a half inch higher than where the bale bar would have been. It was pulled in closer than you, deeper into the turn of the shank and getting snug that way. In your case it appears you are getting snug by pulling it in tight against the bale bar.
So to me, what you show is nothing but good news for me. It works with no changes at all to the stock roller assembly. That takes off of my must-do-immediately list the need to do something about this.
Leaving 4 options. There is no way I'd choose between them from an armchair perspective. Need the boat and anchor and experience with it, and then choose a preference. But seems to me all 4 can work, and its about preference.
1) Leave everything as-is and do it your way
2) Remove the bale bar and snug it deeper into the turn of the shank, as per the example sent to me in pictures months ago.
3) Remove the bale bar, but add in a hoop style bar, just so it doesn't get loose bouncing in some head seas
4) #3, but add the Mantus gadget so that it snugs against that.
The obvious path is start your way with #1, and take it from there.
Many thanks for sharing that.