I really hate my 4 stroke dinghy ob

The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
Dougcole

Dougcole

Guru
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
2,220
Location
USA
Vessel Name
Morgan
Vessel Make
'05 Mainship 40T
So my 2006 15hp 2 stroke Johnson was stolen some months back. Due to governmental stupidity (is there any other kind?) we can no longer buy small 2 strokes in the US.

I had insurance on my old motor and Allstate was nice enough to buy me a new motor of my choice. Afetr a good bit of research I went with a 20 hp Suzuki. I have it on a Caribe L1011 (10'6") RIB. I was going to buy a 15hp, but the 15hp and the 20hp weigh the exact same and are the same size, so I went with the extra HP. Glad I did or the situation would be even worse. Also, the Suzuki is the lightest 15 or 20 hp 4 stroke on the market, though not by much.

Now, before you old sailors tell me I have too big a motor, our crew consists of me (170lbs) my wife, 15 YO son (140lbs and growing) 11 YO son (80lbs and growing) and black lab (80 lbs). We cruise in the Bahamas and need to cover long distances. We tow a knee board. We fish and snorkel on near in reefs, we spear fish, we haul big loads of groceries and sometimes water. An little 6hp putt along just doesn't work for us.

So the old motor was top end 3 mph faster, much, much quicker out of the hole, smaller to store, easier to get off the dink into the big boat, easier to start, idled better, accelerated smoother and balanced the dinghy better.

The new one burns about 1/2 the fuel (who cares, we used to burn 18 gallons in a 3 week trip, now we burn 9) and is quieter. Other than that it sucks.

I'm thinking I'm going to have to move up to a 12' dinghy. Which means bigger davits.

Anyone want to trade a really good 2 stroke 15 for a brand new 2013 20 hp Suzuki? I'm serious.
 
On the exact same dinghy, I used a 20 Yamaha 2 stroke. It had power enough to be scary with just me (160 lb) at the tiller, so I added a dolphin to the bottom of the outboard and "Smart-tabs" to the transom. That settled it down nicely. With your extra weight (both you and the 4 stroke) you may get away with only the dolphin to settle your down.
I bought the 20 Yam 2 when my 15 Merc died, on the recommendation of the Merc/Honda dealer, who told me Yam had the best power to weight ratio.
If you shop the used market, you might still find a 20 Yam 2, which starts easy, runs quiet, uses a little more fuel, makes a tiny bit of smoke (100 to 1 mix), so has all of what you want.
I now run a Caribe 12 with a Honda 40 4 stroke. I like it! Faster out of the hole, sips fuel, quiet, room in the dink for the Prawn hauler, traps, etc, dry ride, console steering. I had to beef up my davits for the heavy lift, and I don't lift as often. Tows well.
 
I feel your pain

I have a Yamaha 20 hp 4 stroke on a 10'6 Zodiak Rib. My old Mercury 15 which I still own is about half the weight, starts easier, has better controls , and is faster. I did learn a trick on starting the Yamaha, The carburetor has a accelerator pump and you can facilitate starting by twisting the throttle a couple of time to prime the engine for cold starts. Just like we used to do old carburetor-ed cars. The rope pull on that 20hp Yamaha is about all I can do and I doubt a average sized woman could rope start it.
 
I might start looking at the used market. My guess is that I could sell this Suzuki to some sap who believes the crap about 4 strokes being better and cover the costs of the used motor.

Thanks for the advice on the dolfin, I've been thinking of trying that. Right now though, I have to store the motor in my lazzarette, clamped to a stringer, as we don't yet have davits on the new boat, and I don't think it will fit in there with the dolfin. That is for sure my next step though after davits of some sort.

Do you find with the dolfin that after you get out of the hole it continues to trim the bow down? On our dinghy I slide forward to get it up on plane then slide back to get the bow out a little, otherwise it sticks in turns and can get pretty scary to run.

Another annoying habit of the 4 stroke is that the pull cord "sticks" about 1/3 through every third or fourth pull. It really hurts when you are pulling hard and expecting the cord to come all the way out.
 
We have a 15 HP Suzuki and it's clearly the star among 4-stroke offerings. Great little motor. Our Nick Jackson davit easily lifts the dink with motor. Anybody with a 2-stroke should jump at a trade.
 
"Do you find with the dolfin that after you get out of the hole it continues to trim the bow down? On our dinghy I slide forward to get it up on plane then slide back to get the bow out a little, otherwise it sticks in turns and can get pretty scary to run."

IIRC, the dolfin didn't do much to keep the bow down after getting up on a plane. The smarttabs did lots of that though.

My experience was that with just me in the stern, the 20 Yam felt like it had enough punch to flip end over end. When I added the Dolfin, it would rise to a 45 deg angle, but go no further, then flatten out after getting up to speed. It rode fairly level, not too different than with no trim aids. With Dolfin and Smart-tabs, it would stay fairly level as it came out of the hole and ride bow down once it was up to full speed. Got to love Smart-tabs.
Get over it and go to the 12' with at least 30 hp. You won't regret it.
 
A boater in the same marina I'm camped at offered me a straight-up trade for my old Merc 9.9 for his new 4 stroke Merc/Tohatsu 9.9. I nearly jumped at it, but when I felt the size and weight of his four stroke and compared the performance, I said "no thanks". A week later, he paid top dollar for the best 9.9 two-stroke Merc he could find and took a big loss selling his four-stroke to the first guy that came to look at it. He's happy.
 
Dougcole said:
I might start looking at the used market. My guess is that I could sell this Suzuki to some sap who believes the crap about 4 strokes being better and cover the costs of the used motor.

Thanks for the advice on the dolfin, I've been thinking of trying that. Right now though, I have to store the motor in my lazzarette, clamped to a stringer, as we don't yet have davits on the new boat, and I don't think it will fit in there with the dolfin. That is for sure my next step though after davits of some sort.

Do you find with the dolfin that after you get out of the hole it continues to trim the bow down? On our dinghy I slide forward to get it up on plane then slide back to get the bow out a little, otherwise it sticks in turns and can get pretty scary to run.

Another annoying habit of the 4 stroke is that the pull cord "sticks" about 1/3 through every third or fourth pull. It really hurts when you are pulling hard and expecting the cord to come all the way out.
Click to expand...

How long have you had the motor?... thought of taking it back to the dealer and tell him your majorly unsatisfied?
I had a 10hp Honda that was a piece of crap and I practically gave it away to get rid of the overweight P.O.S.
For a dinghy that has to be lifted on davits nothing beats a 2 stroke.
Get on Craigslist and search inland and find a good later model 2 stroke that has been used only in fresh water.. then go forth and be happy!
HOLLYWOOD
 
hollywood8118 says;

"Get on Craigslist and search inland and find a good later model 2 stroke that has been used only in fresh water.. then go forth and be happy!"

YES. Good 2 strokes should be found for some time to come but the ethanol issue muddy's the picture. I've got a 70 somth'in 6hp Johnson and I ain't part'in w it.


HopCar I probably sold one of your bad breath engines yesterday. I told a friend about them and he sounded like he needed to go right down and get one.
 
Last edited:
Couldnt you just by a 2 stroke in the Bahamas, they just don't sell them in the USA. Also noticed that Canada still sells 2 strokes as well. Just a thought.
 
Marlinmike said:
Couldnt you just by a 2 stroke in the Bahamas, they just don't sell them in the USA. Also noticed that Canada still sells 2 strokes as well. Just a thought.
Click to expand...

Maybe Canada. Prices in the Bahamas are 50 to 100% higher than US. I don't go there to buy anything except Bahama coconut bread.
 
So who makes the 2stroke OBs available in the Bahamas?
 
I don't know about the Bahamas, but you can buy Tohatsu/Nissan, Yamaha or Mercury 2 strokes throughout most of the Caribbean. This past spring we bought a new Tohatsu 9.8hp, 2 stroke for $1,950 US in St. Martins with no tax or duty.
 
And I thought I was the lone hold out. I bought a 2 stroke Johnson the last year they were legal in CA and I will not buy a 4 stroke. I use synthetic 2 stroke oil that is biodegradable too. I can pull my plugs and they are whitish grey. Starts and runs great.

I have 2 25hp johnsons with electric start that are 2 stroke. I have one on a 14' Glasspar that's a 62 or close. It's a classic runabout and the Johnson makes for scary rides.

I'd part with one of the Johnson 25 hp. It's old, don't know the year. It's been stored for the last 6 years.
 
Capthead,
The best full synthetic 2 stroke oil is BelRay MC-1 ll. It's so viscous it it not recommended for oil injection. It's a racing oil that must be pre-mixed. Costs about $60 a gallon too. Mix at 50-1. Must be mixed thoroughly initially but does not separate.

But in a low temp sea water cooled engine you don't need MC-1 at all. I just use a good dino oil for outboards.
 
I was buying redline racing synthetic 2 stroke oil but a few years ago I was in a Johnson repair shop and they were selling Johnson fully synthetic 2 stroke oil by the gallon for 12.00 so I bought a few. They said it was a close out and they discontinued it. It works great actually and for 12 bucks how can I go wrong?

If I can't find a good source for synthetic after I run out, I might go back to dyno.
 
Capthead said:
I was buying redline racing synthetic 2 stroke oil but a few years ago I was in a Johnson repair shop and they were selling Johnson fully synthetic 2 stroke oil by the gallon for 12.00 so I bought a few. They said it was a close out and they discontinued it. It works great actually and for 12 bucks how can I go wrong?

If I can't find a good source for synthetic after I run out, I might go back to dyno.
Click to expand...

Captnhead,
Go to your friendly Evinrude dealer and check out the 100% synthetic oil sold w their name on the bottle formulated for water cooled Evinrude outboards. That's what I use in my e-tec. I run my e-tec on a computer setting of 50-1. I've not pulled a plug so can't report plug color but it never smokes at all and I've even used it trolling all afternoon for salmon.

Did the Johnson dealer you mentioned sell the e-tec Evinrude engines? They should have that oil.???
 
Last edited:
sounds like you guys have already lived the mistake I am/was about to make. We have 11ft walker bay rib rated 25hp max and 15hp min. I was going to buy 20 hp Yamaha as it weighs same as 15 and about 65lbs lighter than the 25. You guys say these 4 strokes suck performance and weight wise, but a used ie. unknown 2 stroke? that sounds like trouble too
 
20 Suzuki

I recently bought an injected electric start 20 hp Suzuki. It planes my 10 Avon rib at half throttle with 2 on board and if I am alone will plane after a moderate bow lift. I fought old 2strokes for 2 years. If I could have bought a new electric 2 stroke I would have. I will say it is super quiet, smells good and in 3 days running have burned about a gallon of gas. I love the electric start with a 15 pound lawn mower battery.
 
Yeah, I have a 10' center console Avon, which is very heavy. A 15 Suzuki 4 stroke gets it on plane with the spouse and me plus an Airedale Terrier...well over 400 pounds total. I did have an issue with a misadjusted throttle lever stop restricting max rpm, but the power complaint is way overblown.
 
These are all fine if you leave them on a raft and crane them up, but there is significant hp:weight ratio changes from a 2 stroke from 4 stroke. For me it would nice to have options rather then being dictated to from the DEC, I mean come on, a 10hp motor and emissions?
 
gotfw wrote

"Did I mention........I love the electric start!!!"

What for .. so you don't have to pull on a rope once or twice? Fully engaged in the bush button world? My wife starts our old Johnson 6 easily. She really likes it. When it's tuned right.

A battery and the starter motor are really heavy. My 40hp e-tec is heavy and my 60hp Suzuki is very heavy both electric start. I wouldn't order them as manuals at my age but a 10 or 15hp? Seems nuts to me. The 4 stroke feature w all the valves, cam, oil pump ect ect plus an electric starting motor and a heavy battery ... seems nuts.
 
The battery weighs less than 15 pounds, the motor 106 pounds, I have bursitis in my shoulder, this works for me. The engine is extremely hard to hand crank.
By the way I am using a modern keyboard and electric computer also. I gave up rotary dial and hand cranks a long time ago. My post was to show what works for me. If anyone wants to hand crank a 75 horsepower like I did 57 years ago have at it. Lets contribute useful information, not opinions that are negative and irrelevant to the original post.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

H
Help choosing 15hp dingy motor
Replies
27
Views
2K
lwarden
lwarden
G
Outboard mounting bolts
Replies
5
Views
918
tiltrider1
tiltrider1
W
Yanmar 4LV pump problem
Replies
16
Views
860
Mac2
Mac2
Cargile
Gasser on the Great Loop?
2
Replies
43
Views
1K
slowgoesit
slowgoesit
G
Intro--I hope I'm doing this right
Replies
7
Views
565
Mambo42
Mambo42

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom